H4D (1.0 SCe, Mercedes M281) vs M160/M160E
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Higher reliability score
H4D (1.0 SCe, Mercedes M281)
BUY
80/100
+34 points over M160/M160E
0
/ 100
BUY
H4D (1.0 SCe, Mercedes M281)
Smart
0
/ 100
AVOID
M160/M160E
Smart
Specifications
H4D (1.0 SCe, Mercedes M281)
M160/M160E
Brand
Smart
Smart
Verdict
BUY
AVOID
Reliability
80
46
Years
2014--present
1998--2007
Displacement
999 cc
599 cc
Layout
I3
I3
Type
Petrol Na
Petrol Turbo
Power
61--73 hp
45--101 hp
Known Issues
5
7
Total Risk Cost
€450--€1,150
€1,100--€3,000
Character
H4D (1.0 SCe, Mercedes M281)
"Renault's simple 1.0 three-cylinder without a turbo (H4D, called M281 by Mercedes): Smart Fortwo/Forfour 453, Twingo III, Clio V, Sandero and Logan. Slow but owners report few faults; watch oil use after about 100,000 km and have the valve clearance checked, as there are no hydraulic lifters. Not the 0.9 TCe turbo (H4B)."
M160/M160E
"Mercedes' tiny three-cylinder turbo (599 cc, 698 cc from 2003) in the Smart City Coupe/Fortwo 450 and Roadster. The turbo and exhaust manifold are the weak points, oil consumption shows up early, and the timing chain can need attention by 50,000-80,000 km. The automated gearbox's clutch actuator is the most common workshop job. Check the oil level often."
Issues Comparison
H4D (1.0 SCe, Mercedes M281) 5
● MODERATE
Thermostat failure
○ MINOR
Oil consumption and leaks after about 100,000 km
○ MINOR
Lambda sensor and sensor faults - engine stutters
○ MINOR
Ignition coil failure
○ MINOR
Engine mount vibration
M160/M160E 7
◆ CRITICAL
Head gasket failure
▲ HIGH
Turbocharger and exhaust manifold failure
▲ HIGH
Clutch actuator failure (automated gearbox)
▲ HIGH
Overheating (rear-mount cooling)
● MODERATE
Oil consumption and oil leaks - burnt valves if neglected
● MODERATE
Timing chain wear
● MODERATE
ECU / immobilizer fault