4.2 V8 FSI (BAR/BVJ/BNS/BYH/CAU/CFSA) vs EA888 Gen 3 (2.0 TSI/TFSI)
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
4.2 V8 FSI (BAR/BVJ/BNS/BYH/CAU/CFSA)
"Direct-injection 4.2 V8 of the RS4 B7, R8, RS5, Q7, A6 C6 and A8 D3. Sweet and high-revving, generally robust. Carbon builds on the intake valves, and the rear-mounted timing chain is an engine-out job if its guides wear - reports conflict on how often that happens on the FSI. Not the 40-valve S4 B6/B7 engine."
EA888 Gen 3 (2.0 TSI/TFSI)
"The third-generation 2.0 TSI/TFSI (about 2012-2020): Golf 7 GTI and R, Audi A3/S3 8V, A4/A5 B9, TT 8S, Skoda Octavia RS, Superb and Kodiaq, SEAT Leon Cupra, Passat B8 and Tiguan. Timing chain, port plus direct injection, and a big step on from the oil-burning, tensioner-prone Gen 1/2. Its known weak point is the plastic water pump and thermostat housing, which often leaks before 100,000 km; Audi revised the repair procedure and a US class action settled over the pump. The PCV valve diaphragm in the valve cover tears, and the intake valves still collect some carbon. Check the coolant level and the repair history before buying."