1.6 TDI CR EA189 (CAYA/CAYB/CAYC) vs 1.9 TDI VE (1Z/AHU/AFN/ALH/ASV/AHF/AGR)
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Higher reliability score
1.9 TDI VE (1Z/AHU/AFN/ALH/ASV/AHF/AGR)
BEST
89/100
+19 points over 1.6 TDI CR EA189 (CAYA/CAYB/CAYC)
0
/ 100
ACCEPTABLE
1.6 TDI CR EA189 (CAYA/CAYB/CAYC)
Volkswagen
0
/ 100
BEST
1.9 TDI VE (1Z/AHU/AFN/ALH/ASV/AHF/AGR)
Volkswagen
Specifications
1.6 TDI CR EA189 (CAYA/CAYB/CAYC)
1.9 TDI VE (1Z/AHU/AFN/ALH/ASV/AHF/AGR)
Brand
Volkswagen
Volkswagen
Verdict
ACCEPTABLE
BEST
Reliability
70
89
Years
2009--2015
1991--2006
Displacement
1598 cc
1896 cc
Layout
I4
I4
Type
Diesel
Diesel
Power
75--105 hp
75--110 hp
Known Issues
4
8
Total Risk Cost
€1,655--€2,700
€1,571--€4,540
Character
1.6 TDI CR EA189 (CAYA/CAYB/CAYC)
"First common-rail 1.6 TDI and the Dieselgate engine. Economical and long-lived at the bottom end, but Siemens piezo injectors fail from 80,000 km and the EGR cooler clogs or fails early - both expensive and both more likely after the 2016 emissions retrofit on a worn engine. Buy with injector and EGR invoices or budget for them."
1.9 TDI VE (1Z/AHU/AFN/ALH/ASV/AHF/AGR)
"The rotary-pump TDI that built the legend. Simple VP37 injection, 500,000 km examples are documented. Weak spots are wear items: injection-pump seals, VTG turbo vanes, EGR soot and the dual-mass flywheel. Keep the timing belt on schedule - it is an interference engine."
Issues Comparison
1.6 TDI CR EA189 (CAYA/CAYB/CAYC) 4
▲ HIGH
Siemens piezo injector failure (2009-2013 builds)
▲ HIGH
Timing belt and water pump - interference engine
▲ HIGH
EGR cooler and valve clogging or failure - limp mode
● MODERATE
DPF clogging on short trips
1.9 TDI VE (1Z/AHU/AFN/ALH/ASV/AHF/AGR) 8
▲ HIGH
Timing belt - interference engine, 60,000-120,000 km interval by variant
▲ HIGH
Timing belt replacement — interference engine
● MODERATE
VP37 injection pump seals and electronics wear
● MODERATE
VTG turbo vanes and actuator sticking (AFN/ALH/ASV)
● MODERATE
Dual-mass flywheel wear
○ MINOR
EGR valve sooting and intake clogging
○ MINOR
Turbo wear at very high mileage
○ MINOR
Injection pump wear (very high mileage)