OM660 0.8 CDI vs M134 E11 / 3A91
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
OM660 0.8 CDI
"0.8-litre three-cylinder common-rail diesel with a timing chain, used only in the Smart fortwo W450 and W451. Tougher than its size suggests: owners report 250,000 km and more, one W450 reached 375,000 km on its original turbo. The EGR valve clogs with soot and needs cleaning, the turbo wears out from around 140,000 km, and the 54 hp Euro 5 version (from 2009) has a DPF that blocks in city use and pressure and temperature sensors that put it into limp mode. The pre-DPF 41/45 hp versions are the simpler buy."
M134 E11 / 3A91
"Mitsubishi 1.1 three-cylinder petrol (3A91, 75 hp), called M134 by Mercedes: Smart Forfour 454 1.1 (2004-2006) and Mitsubishi Colt Z30 1.1 (2004-2012). Port injection, timing chain, no turbo. Owners mostly report a trouble-free engine. The known weak points are oil consumption from thin piston rings from about 100,000 km and a timing chain that often needs replacing after about 150,000 km. No hydraulic lifters, so the valve clearance needs periodic checks. Not the 1.0/1.2 3A90/3A92 of the later Space Star."