P9X vs K4J
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
P9X
"Isuzu-built 3.0 V6 common-rail diesel (Isuzu 6DE1, also Opel Y30DT and Saab 9-5 3.0 TiD) in the Renault Espace IV and Vel Satis, 2002-2010: 177 hp (P9X 701) and 181 hp (P9X 715). Strong and refined, but in Renault's hot, cramped engine bays the early engines overheat: cylinder liners settle, head gaskets fail and engines seize - French media call it far from a success and Renault paid for some replacement engines. The 2005 update is said to be much better. Injection pumps and the six injectors, the EGR valve and the variable-geometry turbo are other common faults. The camshafts are driven by a belt (Renault interval 200,000 km), not a chain. Check the cooling system, coolant level and expansion tank, and ask whether the engine has ever been replaced."
K4J
"1.4-litre 16-valve petrol of the K family, found in the Clio II and III, Megane, Scenic and Modus. A durable, simple engine whose main risk is the timing belt: it is an interference engine, so a failed tensioner, idler or water pump that lets the belt slip bends the valves - change the full kit on time. Otherwise expect cheap electrical faults: ignition coils, the crankshaft sensor and a dirty throttle body."