F9Q (1997-2005, Euro 3) vs V4Y / VQ35DE
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
F9Q (1997-2005, Euro 3)
"Early 1.9 diesel in the Megane, Scenic, Laguna, Clio, Trafic, Volvo S40/V40 and Mitsubishi Carisma: mechanical-pump dTi from 1997, common-rail dCi from 1999. The 2000-2005 dCi engines are the ones to avoid: connecting-rod bearings can wear out and destroy the engine (a French court called it a hidden defect), and turbos failed often. EGR valves and air-mass meters clog. Timing belt - keep to the schedule and check the accessory belt."
V4Y / VQ35DE
"Nissan's VQ35DE 3.5 V6, sold by Renault as the V4Y in the Espace IV, Vel Satis, Laguna III Coupe and Latitude (and by Nissan in the Murano). A chain-driven aluminium V6 that specialist sources expect to last 350,000-400,000 km; Nissan calls its V6 engines typically trouble-free. The known weak spots are the timing-chain guides and tensioner shoes, which can wear or break and rattle (Nissan issued a service bulletin with upgraded parts), crankshaft and camshaft sensors that could stall early engines, and cooling parts such as the water pump and fan. Use good fuel and fix misfires quickly, because a failing catalytic converter can shed debris into the engine and raise oil consumption. Thirsty, but far less troublesome than the diesels in the same cars."