F9Q (1997-2005, Euro 3) vs G8T
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
F9Q (1997-2005, Euro 3)
"Early 1.9 diesel in the Megane, Scenic, Laguna, Clio, Trafic, Volvo S40/V40 and Mitsubishi Carisma: mechanical-pump dTi from 1997, common-rail dCi from 1999. The 2000-2005 dCi engines are the ones to avoid: connecting-rod bearings can wear out and destroy the engine (a French court called it a hidden defect), and turbos failed often. EGR valves and air-mass meters clog. Timing belt - keep to the schedule and check the accessory belt."
G8T
"Renault's old 2.2-litre indirect-injection diesel (G8T, 1993-2002): 83 hp without turbo and 110-113 hp with turbo, in the Laguna I, Espace III and Safrane. Slow and noisy but very long-lived - owners report 360,000-600,000 km and a specialist site expects about 500,000 km. The timing belt is the main risk: a slack belt, a tired tensioner or a frayed accessory belt can make it jump or break and damage the rocker arms, so French owners change belt, tensioner and water pump together about every 100,000-120,000 km. Overheating can warp or crack the head, and the oil-cooler seals leak with age. The naturally aspirated 2.2 D has a weaker record than the turbo version. No common rail and no particulate filter."