ES9 3.0 V6 vs DW8 1.9D
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
ES9 3.0 V6
"PSA-Renault 3.0 V6 (60 degrees, belt-driven, 1997-2010), called ES9 at Peugeot and Citroen (406, 407, 607, 807, C5, C6, C8) and L7X at Renault (Laguna, Espace, Safrane, Avantime and the mid-engined Clio V6, up to 255 hp). It replaced the old PRV V6 and is mechanically durable (300,000-350,000 km quoted), but ignition coils are a frequent failure, the cooling system (thermostat, trapped air) can overheat the engine, oil seeps from gaskets and the timing belt is an expensive job (around EUR 1,100) that must not be skipped. Peugeot and Citroen versions have four costly lambda sensors and intake variable valve timing from 2000."
DW8 1.9D
"PSA's simple 1.9 naturally aspirated diesel (DW8, 69-71 hp, indirect injection, Lucas distributor pump, no turbo, no common rail) in the Peugeot 206, 306, Partner and Expert, Citroen Xsara, Berlingo and Jumpy, Fiat Scudo and the Toyota Corolla 1.9 D, until it failed Euro 4 in 2007. Slow and noisy but very durable: an engine database rates its life at about 400,000 km, and French owners report DW8 vans and 206s past 320,000-350,000 km. Weak points are the timing belt (change it on time; a snapped auxiliary belt can damage it), injection-pump timing faults that cause knocking and flat spots around 2,000 rpm, and an oil-sweating valve cover. Owners replace clutches and clutch cables far more often than anything in the engine."