Higher reliability score
9A1/MA1 BEST 85/100
+3 points over M46 (3.0 M46.30, 3.6 M46.35)
0 / 100
BEST 9A1/MA1 Porsche
0 / 100
BUY M46 (3.0 M46.30, 3.6 M46.35) Porsche

Specifications

9A1/MA1
M46 (3.0 M46.30, 3.6 M46.35)
Brand
Porsche
Porsche
Verdict
BEST
BUY
Reliability
85
82
Years
2008--2019
2014--2018
Displacement
3800 cc
3604 cc
Layout
F6
V6
Type
Petrol Na
Petrol Turbo
Power
350--400 hp
340--440 hp
Known Issues
1
2
Total Risk Cost
€0--€0
€4,650--€14,200

Character

9A1/MA1

"Porsche's second-generation water-cooled flat-six with direct injection (9A1/MA1): 997.2 and 991.1 Carrera, 987.2 and 981 Boxster and Cayman, 2.7 to 3.8 litres. A closed-deck crankcase, integrated dry sump and front-mounted timing chains removed the IMS bearing that haunted the M96/M97. Specialists still see occasional bore scoring and piston seizures, mostly blamed on hard driving with a cold engine, so let it warm up before high revs and inspect with a borescope before buying. Direct injection dilutes the oil with fuel: shorter oil-change intervals are advised."

M46 (3.0 M46.30, 3.6 M46.35)

"Porsche's own M46 twin-turbo V6 - 3.0 litres in the Macan S and GTS and the Panamera S (970), 3.6 litres in the Macan Turbo and the Cayenne S and GTS (958) - used until 2018, before the VW-Audi EA839 V6 took over. Strong and smooth. The best-known fault is oil leaking from the timing-case cover when its aluminium bolts break; the repair can mean taking the engine out. Plastic coolant pipes can split and dump the coolant suddenly, and Porsche has a bulletin for coolant leaks at the regulator housing and pump. Check underneath for oil and coolant before buying."

Issues Comparison

9A1/MA1 1

◆ CRITICAL
Bore scoring and piston seizure (rare) N/A--N/A N/A--N/A

M46 (3.0 M46.30, 3.6 M46.35) 2

▲ HIGH
Coolant loss: plastic coolant pipes burst, regulator housing or pump leaks €1,850--€3,200 N/A--N/A
▲ HIGH
Timing-case cover oil leak from broken aluminium bolts €2,800--€11,000 33,000 km--161,000 km

Models

Full 9A1/MA1 Report Full M46 (3.0 M46.30, 3.6 M46.35) Report