1.7 CDTi (Z17DTH/Z17DTJ/Z17DTR/A17DTS/A17DTR/A17DTE/A17DTC) vs A28NET/A28NER 2.8T V6
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
1.7 CDTi (Z17DTH/Z17DTJ/Z17DTR/A17DTS/A17DTR/A17DTE/A17DTC)
"Isuzu-designed 1.7 diesel built in Poland for the Astra, Corsa, Meriva, Zafira and Combo. Noisy and peaky (torque at 2,300 rpm) but durable: owners report 250,000-300,000 km. Typical faults are the EGR valve, injectors (Denso parts are dear), injector-sleeve coolant leaks, the turbo and its control valve, and the DPF on 2007-on versions in city use. Use proper coolant and change the timing belt on time."
A28NET/A28NER 2.8T V6
"GM 2.8 turbo V6 (the Saab and Vectra OPC engine) in the Insignia 2.8 V6 Turbo 4x4 and Insignia OPC/VXR. Strong and fast, but two weak spots: stretched timing chains, mostly on cars built before 2011 (a revised chain kit exists), and leaking exhaust manifolds that can hurt the turbo. Check for engine-light history and poor running, and look at the four-wheel-drive Haldex and rear axle too."