Higher reliability score
HR12DDR BEST 89/100
+17 points over QR20/QR25
0 / 100
ACCEPTABLE QR20/QR25 Nissan
0 / 100
BEST HR12DDR Nissan

Specifications

QR20/QR25
HR12DDR
Brand
Nissan
Nissan
Verdict
ACCEPTABLE
BEST
Reliability
72
89
Years
2000--2013
2011--2020
Displacement
2488 cc
1198 cc
Layout
I4
I3
Type
Petrol Na
Petrol Supercharged
Power
140--180 hp
98 hp
Known Issues
5
2
Total Risk Cost
€740--€1,480
€0--€0

Character

QR20/QR25

"Nissan's chain-driven 2.0 (QR20DE) and 2.5 (QR25DE) petrol four, used in Europe in the X-Trail T30 and T31, the Primera P12 and the Renault Koleos. Engines built up to about 2004-2006 are the weak ones: the pre-catalyst could break up and its ceramic was drawn into the cylinders, scoring the bores, and loose screws from the intake-manifold flaps could drop into the engine; US recalls also covered piston-ring oil consumption and crank-sensor stalling. Specialist guides say engines from 2007 are much better. Check the oil level often, listen for chain rattle after 150,000 km, and look for proof of recall work. With care they reach 300,000 km."

HR12DDR

"Nissan's 1.2 three-cylinder with direct injection and a small Eaton supercharger (98 hp), used in the Micra K13 and Note E12. It runs a Miller cycle with a 13:1 compression ratio and a timing chain. German used-car guides recommend it over the 80 hp non-supercharged 1.2 and report no serious engine faults; the supercharger itself has no documented failure pattern. Watch for injector and intake carbon build-up at high mileage, and check that cars built mid-2015 to January 2016 had the free ignition-coil recall done. No hydraulic lifters, so valve clearances need periodic checks."

Issues Comparison

QR20/QR25 5

▲ HIGH
Intake-manifold flap screws work loose and fall into the engine (to 2005-2006) N/A--N/A N/A--N/A
▲ HIGH
Oil consumption from worn or poorly sealing piston rings N/A--N/A 100,000 km--150,000 km
▲ HIGH
Pre-catalyst break-up: ceramic drawn into the cylinders (early engines) N/A--N/A N/A--N/A
● MODERATE
Crankshaft / camshaft position sensor faults: engine can stall N/A--N/A N/A--N/A
● MODERATE
Timing chain stretch €740--€1,480 150,000 km--200,000 km

HR12DDR 2

● MODERATE
Ignition coil short circuit can stall the engine (recall, cars built 2015-2016) N/A--N/A N/A--N/A
● MODERATE
Injector and intake carbon build-up (direct injection, high mileage) N/A--N/A N/A--N/A

Models

Full QR20/QR25 Report Full HR12DDR Report