MR20DE vs VQ40DE
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
MR20DE
"Port-injected 2.0 in the Qashqai J10 and X-Trail T31. Simple and long-lived if serviced, but two things show up with age: oil consumption (often a failed crankcase breather, sometimes rings) and timing-chain stretch, which has destroyed some engines. Check the oil level and listen to a cold start. Pair it with the manual gearbox if you can - the CVT is the weaker part. The direct-injection MR20DD is a separate engine."
VQ40DE
"Nissan's 4.0 V6 from the VQ family, in the Pathfinder R51 and the US Frontier and Xterra pickups. The engine itself is durable (an engine database quotes about 500,000 km) and chain-driven. The big known fault is outside the engine: on 2005-2010 automatics the radiator's built-in transmission cooler can crack and let coolant into the gearbox, which Nissan covered with an extended warranty in the US. 2011-2012 cars had a recall for oil-cooler bolts. Owners also report whining or rattling timing chains as the guides wear. Check the transmission fluid for coolant and listen for chain noise."