OM651 (early) vs OM612
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Higher reliability score
OM612
BEST
92/100
+26 points over OM651 (early)
0
/ 100
CAUTION
OM651 (early)
Mercedes-Benz
0
/ 100
BEST
OM612
Mercedes-Benz
Specifications
OM651 (early)
OM612
Brand
Mercedes-Benz
Mercedes-Benz
Verdict
CAUTION
BEST
Reliability
66
92
Years
2008--2014
1999--2006
Displacement
2143 cc
2685 cc
Layout
I4
I5
Type
Diesel
Diesel
Power
136--204 hp
156--231 hp
Known Issues
4
2
Total Risk Cost
€3,100--€5,000
€280--€0
Character
OM651 (early)
"The 2008-2014 OM651. The 220 CDI (to 2010/11) and 250 CDI had failure-prone piezo injectors, the 200 CDI never did. Rear-mounted chain wears from about 150,000 km and early tensioners were weak; 2009 water pumps leaked. Well-kept highway cars pass 300,000 km."
OM612
"Smooth, torquey 2.7 five-cylinder common-rail diesel (1999-2006): E 270 CDI W210/W211, C 270 CDI W203, CLK 270 CDI, ML 270 CDI W163, Sprinter 2.7 CDI and the 231 PS C 30 CDI AMG. Its known weak point is the injector copper seals ("black death") - cheap if caught early, expensive once the injectors seize. Good long-distance engine when maintained."
Issues Comparison
OM651 (early) 4
◆ CRITICAL
Timing chain stretch and tensioner wear (rear-mounted chain)
▲ HIGH
DPF + EGR fouling (city use)
▲ HIGH
Piezo injector failure — 220 CDI (to 2010/11) and 250 CDI
● MODERATE
Water pump leak (March-July 2009 build) and cylinder-head coolant stub
OM612 2
● MODERATE
Injector seal leak (Black Death)
○ MINOR
Turbocharger wear at high mileage