FIRE 1.2 8V/16V vs 2.3 JTD/MJT
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Higher reliability score
FIRE 1.2 8V/16V
BEST
88/100
+10 points over 2.3 JTD/MJT
0
/ 100
BEST
FIRE 1.2 8V/16V
Fiat
0
/ 100
BUY
2.3 JTD/MJT
Fiat
Specifications
FIRE 1.2 8V/16V
2.3 JTD/MJT
Brand
Fiat
Fiat
Verdict
BEST
BUY
Reliability
88
78
Years
1993--2020
2002--2021
Displacement
1242 cc
2287 cc
Layout
I4
I4
Type
Petrol Na
Diesel
Power
60--80 hp
120--180 hp
Known Issues
5
5
Total Risk Cost
€15--€0
€0--€4,100
Character
FIRE 1.2 8V/16V
"Simple belt-driven 1.2 that powered the Panda, Punto and 500 for over 20 years. 300,000-400,000 km without major work is documented. Slow, but cheap to fix at any workshop. Keep the belt on time - the 16V and the later VVT 8V are interference engines."
2.3 JTD/MJT
"Fiat/FPT 2.3 MultiJet diesel in the Ducato van and camper base (120-180 hp), replaced by the 2.2 MultiJet3 in 2021. A hard-working engine with the usual diesel wear items: EGR fouling from 80-120k km, leaking injector seals from 100-150k km and turbos on Euro 5 vans from about 150k km. It has a timing belt, not a chain - change it on time, including on campers that sit for months."
Issues Comparison
FIRE 1.2 8V/16V 5
▲ HIGH
Timing belt - 120,000 km interval (interference on 16V and VVT 8V)
● MODERATE
Oil leaks, head gasket seep and oil use on older engines
○ MINOR
Thermostat seal failure - engine runs cold
○ MINOR
Water pump (replace with belt)
○ MINOR
Dirty throttle body - rough idle and stalling
2.3 JTD/MJT 5
▲ HIGH
Injector copper-seal leaks and injector failure
● MODERATE
Timing belt (interference) - time limit matters on campers
● MODERATE
EGR fouling
● MODERATE
Turbocharger failure - more frequent on Euro 5 vans
○ MINOR
Camshaft material defect - can crack (recall, early-2017 builds)