1.9 JTD / JTDm / MultiJet (8v and 16v) vs FireFly 1.0 Hybrid (N3 BSG)
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
1.9 JTD / JTDm / MultiJet (8v and 16v)
"Fiat's 1,910 cc common-rail diesel, launched in the Alfa 156 in 1997 as the first common-rail diesel car, and later sold as 1.9 JTD, JTDm and MultiJet in Fiat, Alfa Romeo and Lancia models, as the Opel/Vauxhall 1.9 CDTI (Astra H, Vectra C, Signum, Zafira B) and as the Saab 1.9 TiD/TTiD (8-valve 80-130 hp, 16-valve 140-170 hp). The core engine is robust and often passes 200,000-300,000 km. The EGR valve is the most common complaint, followed by the dual-mass flywheel and clutch and the alternator. The 16-valve versions (Opel Z19DTH 150 hp) have an intake manifold with swirl flaps that wear and stick. The water pump is driven by the timing belt: if it seizes it can throw the belt and damage the engine, so belt and pump must be changed together and on time."
FireFly 1.0 Hybrid (N3 BSG)
"Naturally aspirated 6-valve FireFly three-cylinder with a timing chain and a 12 V belt starter-generator (BSG) mild-hybrid system, used in the Fiat Panda, Fiat 500 and Lancia Ypsilon Hybrid. Mechanically simple and so far robust; the known faults are in the hybrid electrics - a weak 12 V or auxiliary battery switches off the hybrid and stop-start functions. Too young for long-term mileage evidence."