S85 vs M54
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Higher reliability score
M54
BEST
86/100
+35 points over S85
0
/ 100
CAUTION
S85
BMW
0
/ 100
BEST
M54
BMW
Specifications
S85
M54
Brand
BMW
BMW
Verdict
CAUTION
BEST
Reliability
51
86
Years
2005--2010
2000--2006
Displacement
4999 cc
2979 cc
Layout
V10
I6
Type
Petrol Na
Petrol Na
Power
507 hp
170--231 hp
Known Issues
4
6
Total Risk Cost
€7,000--€17,800
€300--€700
Character
S85
"E60 M5 / E63 M6 V10 with an 8,250 rpm redline - spectacular and expensive to keep. Rod bearings wear out and are treated as a service item at 80,000-100,000 km; VANOS solenoids and pump and the two throttle actuators are the other big bills. Buy only with bearing-service proof or budget for it."
M54
"The last of the simple BMW straight-sixes: smooth, linear and very long-lived (around 330,000 km with proper care). Nothing on it is known to destroy the engine; the bills are age-related plastics and seals - crankcase ventilation, cooling system, DISA flap, VANOS seals and oil leaks."
Issues Comparison
S85 4
◆ CRITICAL
Rod bearing wear — engine destruction if not replaced preventively
▲ HIGH
Throttle actuator failure (two actuators, plastic gears)
▲ HIGH
VANOS solenoids and high-pressure pump / line failure
○ MINOR
High oil consumption
M54 6
● MODERATE
Cooling system plastics — water pump, thermostat, expansion tank
● MODERATE
DISA valve failure (intake manifold flap)
● MODERATE
Double VANOS — solenoid and seal wear
● MODERATE
Crankcase ventilation (CCV) valve and hoses — oil consumption, false air
○ MINOR
Oil leaks — valve cover, oil filter housing and oil pan gaskets
○ MINOR
Camshaft / crankshaft position sensor failure — stalling, rpm hunting