Higher reliability score
S58 BEST 89/100
+20 points over M51
0 / 100
ACCEPTABLE M51 BMW
0 / 100
BEST S58 BMW

Specifications

M51
S58
Brand
BMW
BMW
Verdict
ACCEPTABLE
BEST
Reliability
69
89
Years
1991--2001
2019--present
Displacement
2497 cc
2993 cc
Layout
I6
I6
Type
Diesel
Petrol Turbo
Power
115--143 hp
460--530 hp
Known Issues
6
4
Total Risk Cost
€0--€0
€600--€1,200

Character

M51

"BMW's 2.5-litre six-cylinder turbodiesel with indirect injection and a timing chain (1991-2001), used in the E36 325td/tds, E34 and E39 525td/tds, E38 725tds, Opel Omega B 2.5 TD and Range Rover P38 2.5 DSE. The bottom end is long-lived and owners report cars past 400,000 km, but two things decide a purchase: the electronic Bosch injection pump, which leaks or fails around 180,000-200,000 km, and the aluminium cylinder head, which cracks if the engine overheats. Check the water pump, cooling system and coolant level, and look for oil leaks and a tired turbo on high-mileage cars."

S58

"The 3.0-litre twin-turbo straight-six of the X3 M, X4 M, M3, M4 and M2 (2019 onwards). So far it has proved very tough: AUTO BILD stripped a 100,000 km M3 and found almost no wear, no oil use and no breakdowns. The one manufacturing fault was a batch of main bearing shells in cars built July-September 2021, held back by BMW and repaired before delivery. Otherwise expect normal M-car wear items: crankcase ventilation valve, coolant leaks and spark plugs on hard-driven or tuned cars."

Issues Comparison

M51 6

▲ HIGH
Cylinder head cracking after overheating N/A--N/A N/A--N/A
▲ HIGH
Injection pump leaks or electronic faults (hot and cold start problems) N/A--N/A 180,000 km--200,000 km
● MODERATE
Timing chain stretch N/A--N/A N/A--N/A
● MODERATE
Water pump failure (plastic impeller) N/A--N/A N/A--N/A
● MODERATE
Turbocharger wear at high mileage N/A--N/A 150,000 km--210,000 km
○ MINOR
Oil leaks (sump, oil filter housing, oil lines) N/A--N/A N/A--N/A

S58 4

● MODERATE
Main bearing shell defect - cars built July to September 2021 N/A--N/A N/A--N/A
● MODERATE
Crankcase ventilation (PCV) valve wear - valve cover replacement €400--€800 80,000 km--N/A
○ MINOR
Coolant loss from cooling system leaks N/A--N/A N/A--N/A
○ MINOR
Early spark plug and ignition coil wear on hard-driven or tuned cars €200--€400 30,000 km--N/A

Models

Full M51 Report Full S58 Report