M51 vs S58
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
M51
"BMW's 2.5-litre six-cylinder turbodiesel with indirect injection and a timing chain (1991-2001), used in the E36 325td/tds, E34 and E39 525td/tds, E38 725tds, Opel Omega B 2.5 TD and Range Rover P38 2.5 DSE. The bottom end is long-lived and owners report cars past 400,000 km, but two things decide a purchase: the electronic Bosch injection pump, which leaks or fails around 180,000-200,000 km, and the aluminium cylinder head, which cracks if the engine overheats. Check the water pump, cooling system and coolant level, and look for oil leaks and a tired turbo on high-mileage cars."
S58
"The 3.0-litre twin-turbo straight-six of the X3 M, X4 M, M3, M4 and M2 (2019 onwards). So far it has proved very tough: AUTO BILD stripped a 100,000 km M3 and found almost no wear, no oil use and no breakdowns. The one manufacturing fault was a batch of main bearing shells in cars built July-September 2021, held back by BMW and repaired before delivery. Otherwise expect normal M-car wear items: crankcase ventilation valve, coolant leaks and spark plugs on hard-driven or tuned cars."