M41 vs S58
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Higher reliability score
S58
BEST
89/100
+17 points over M41
0
/ 100
ACCEPTABLE
M41
BMW
0
/ 100
BEST
S58
BMW
Specifications
M41
S58
Brand
BMW
BMW
Verdict
ACCEPTABLE
BEST
Reliability
72
89
Years
1994--1999
2019--present
Displacement
1665 cc
2993 cc
Layout
I4
I6
Type
Diesel
Petrol Turbo
Power
90 hp
460--530 hp
Known Issues
3
4
Total Risk Cost
€650--€1,600
€600--€1,200
Character
M41
"E36 318tds. Pre-common-rail indirect injection. Simple, economical. No swirl flaps, no DPF. Timing belt. Injection pump can fail at very high mileage. Cast iron block. Reliable and cheap. Low power is the only complaint."
S58
"The 3.0-litre twin-turbo straight-six of the X3 M, X4 M, M3, M4 and M2 (2019 onwards). So far it has proved very tough: AUTO BILD stripped a 100,000 km M3 and found almost no wear, no oil use and no breakdowns. The one manufacturing fault was a batch of main bearing shells in cars built July-September 2021, held back by BMW and repaired before delivery. Otherwise expect normal M-car wear items: crankcase ventilation valve, coolant leaks and spark plugs on hard-driven or tuned cars."
Issues Comparison
M41 3
▲ HIGH
Timing belt (interference)
● MODERATE
Injection pump (indirect injection)
○ MINOR
Glow plug failure
S58 4
● MODERATE
Main bearing shell defect - cars built July to September 2021
● MODERATE
Crankcase ventilation (PCV) valve wear - valve cover replacement
○ MINOR
Coolant loss from cooling system leaks
○ MINOR
Early spark plug and ignition coil wear on hard-driven or tuned cars