4.2 TDI V8 vs 5.2 FSI V10
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
4.2 TDI V8
"4.2-litre common-rail V8 diesel built by Audi for the A8 (2005-2017), Q7 (2007-2015) and Porsche Cayenne S Diesel. Huge torque and long-lived if serviced, but expensive when it fails: the timing chains sit at the back of the engine and wear at high mileage, the turbochargers suffer from poor oil, and the piezo injectors dislike bad fuel. Euro 5 and Euro 6 A8s and Euro 6 Cayennes were recalled for an emissions software update. Not the same engine as the 2016+ 4.0 TDI with electric compressor."
5.2 FSI V10
"Naturally aspirated 5.2 direct-injection V10 of the S6 C6, S8 D3 and first-generation R8 V10. No engine recall and few complaints, but it is an expensive engine to keep: intake valves coke up like all FSI engines and need periodic walnut cleaning, and the timing chains sit at the back, so chain or guide work means taking the engine out. Buy with full service history."