VR6 2.8 12V/24V (AAA/AES/AFP/AQP/AUE/AYL/BDE) vs EA211 1.0 MPI (CHYA/CHYB/DLAC/DKRA)
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
VR6 2.8 12V/24V (AAA/AES/AFP/AQP/AUE/AYL/BDE)
"VW's narrow-angle 2.8 VR6, as a 12-valve (174 PS: Golf 3, Corrado, Passat, Sharan) and a 24-valve (204 PS: Golf 4 V6 4MOTION, Leon Cupra 4, Alhambra/Sharan). Wonderful sound and long-lived, around 280,000 km with care. The weak point is the timing-chain tensioner and guides at the gearbox end - a cold-start rattle means a big job, and a jumped chain wrecks the engine. Watch the plastic coolant flanges: overheating can blow the head gasket."
EA211 1.0 MPI (CHYA/CHYB/DLAC/DKRA)
"Naturally aspirated port-injected three-cylinder in the up!, Mii, Citigo, Fabia and Polo. No turbo and no direct-injection carbon; German guides recommend it over the 1.0 TSI. Watch for coolant leaks from the plastic pump/thermostat module, keep the toothed belt on schedule, and change oil on time - early CHYA engines can clog the camshaft-control oil valve."