V10 TDI 5.0 vs 1.8 NA
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
V10 TDI 5.0
"5.0-litre twin-turbo V10 diesel with pump-injector (PD) injection and gear-driven camshafts, fitted only to the first-generation VW Touareg. Huge torque, but one of the most expensive engines to own: the PD camshaft lobes wear (cam and lifter jobs run past 10,000 USD), the ten unit injectors and the tandem pump start leaking around 150,000 km, the turbos are short-lived, and early cars suffered timing-gear failures. Most of these jobs need the engine and gearbox removed first."
1.8 NA
"Simple 1.8-litre 8-valve petrol with single-point Mono-Motronic injection and hydraulic lifters, in the Golf III, Vento, Passat B3/B4, Polo 6N and Seat Ibiza, Cordoba and Toledo. Long-lived: an Auto Bild test car covered 261,724 km in seven years, and specialists quote about 300,000 km. Expect oil leaks from seals and the valve cover, tired lambda and coolant temperature sensors, and an unstable idle from a dirty or split throttle body. Keep the timing belt tensioned and changed on time: a slack belt can jump and wreck the engine."