ES9 3.0 V6 vs XU10 2.0
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
ES9 3.0 V6
"PSA-Renault 3.0 V6 (60 degrees, belt-driven, 1997-2010), called ES9 at Peugeot and Citroen (406, 407, 607, 807, C5, C6, C8) and L7X at Renault (Laguna, Espace, Safrane, Avantime and the mid-engined Clio V6, up to 255 hp). It replaced the old PRV V6 and is mechanically durable (300,000-350,000 km quoted), but ignition coils are a frequent failure, the cooling system (thermostat, trapped air) can overheat the engine, oil seeps from gaskets and the timing belt is an expensive job (around EUR 1,100) that must not be skipped. Peugeot and Citroen versions have four costly lambda sensors and intake variable valve timing from 2000."
XU10 2.0
"PSA XU10 2.0 16-valve petrol of the 1990s: 132-136 hp XU10J4R in the Peugeot 306, 406, 605 and 806 and Citroen Xantia, Xsara and XM, and the 163-167 hp XU10J4RS in the 306 S16/GTI-6 and Xsara VTS. Simple, tough and long-lived (often past 300,000 km) if serviced. The timing belt is the one thing that matters: it can crack before its interval and a broken belt badly damages the engine, so change it every 80,000-100,000 km. Use good oil to avoid sludge and noisy lifters; idle-control and ignition parts are the usual small faults."