DT17 2.7 HDi V6 vs DW8 1.9D
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
DT17 2.7 HDi V6
"Twin-turbo 2.7 V6 diesel developed by PSA and Ford (2004-2010): Peugeot 407 and 607, Citroen C5 II and C6, and as the 2.7 TDV6 in the Jaguar S-Type, XF and XJ and the Land Rover Discovery 3/4 and Range Rover Sport. Smooth and strong, but expensive to own. The worst risk is crankshaft or main-bearing failure, which destroys the engine; the camshafts are driven by a timing belt whose tensioners, and on early engines the oil-pump casing that carries a belt pulley, can fail. Twin turbos, Siemens piezo injectors, plastic coolant housings and the EGR valve are frequent repairs. Buy only with a full service history, short oil-change intervals and the belt and oil pump done."
DW8 1.9D
"PSA's simple 1.9 naturally aspirated diesel (DW8, 69-71 hp, indirect injection, Lucas distributor pump, no turbo, no common rail) in the Peugeot 206, 306, Partner and Expert, Citroen Xsara, Berlingo and Jumpy, Fiat Scudo and the Toyota Corolla 1.9 D, until it failed Euro 4 in 2007. Slow and noisy but very durable: an engine database rates its life at about 400,000 km, and French owners report DW8 vans and 206s past 320,000-350,000 km. Weak points are the timing belt (change it on time; a snapped auxiliary belt can damage it), injection-pump timing faults that cause knocking and flat spots around 2,000 rpm, and an oil-sweating valve cover. Owners replace clutches and clutch cables far more often than anything in the engine."