M96 vs MA3
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
M96
"The first water-cooled Porsche flat-six, used in the 986 Boxster (2.5/2.7/3.2) and 996 Carrera (3.4/3.6), 1997-2005. Lovely to drive, but it carries three expensive risks: the intermediate shaft (IMS) bearing, worst on the single-row bearing of 2000-2005 cars (about 8-10% failures, subject of a US class action); cracked or slipped cylinder liners and "D-chunk" cracks in the Lokasil bores, most common on early 996s; and bore scoring. The rear main seal weeps on many cars. Buy only with proof of an IMS retrofit or a recent inspection, a clean oil filter and a borescope check. The 996 Turbo, GT2 and GT3 use the different Mezger engine."
MA3
"Porsche's 4.0 naturally aspirated flat-six for the 992 911 GT3 and GT3 RS (510-525 PS) and the 718 Cayman GT4 RS (500 PS). Developed for motorsport: 9,000 rpm, individual throttle valves, solid cam finger followers instead of hydraulic lifters, dry-sump lubrication, forged pistons and titanium conrods. It follows the 991.2 GT3 4.0, which cured the 3.8 engine's problems. No engine recall and no failure pattern documented so far, but the engine is young and evidence is thin."