1.6 CDTI B16DTH/B16DTL/B16DTJ/B16DTE/B16DTR (Whisper Diesel) vs X17DTL/Y17DT 1.7d
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
1.6 CDTI B16DTH/B16DTL/B16DTJ/B16DTE/B16DTR (Whisper Diesel)
"Quiet, frugal all-aluminium 1.6 diesel in Astra J/K, Insignia A/B, Zafira Tourer, Meriva B and Mokka. Its weak point is the timing chain at the gearbox end: a cold-start rattle means a EUR 1,200-2,500 engine-out job. Needs motorway runs for the DPF and the free KBA emissions software recall. Buy one with the chain already done or priced in."
X17DTL/Y17DT 1.7d
"Two old 1.7 diesels share this page. The 1994-2000 1.7 TD (X17DTL, 68 hp) in the Astra F and early Astra G is an Opel design with indirect injection. The 2000-2005 1.7 DTI (Y17DT, 75 hp) in the Astra G, Corsa C, Combo C and Meriva A is an Isuzu design with direct injection and a rotary pump (not common rail). Both are simple and long-lived (300,000-400,000 km quoted), with no DPF. The DTI is known for an injection-pump control unit that fails through dry solder joints and makes the engine cut out or not start. Both use a timing belt that must be changed early, and on the DTI an oil-pump seal can leak onto it."