YD25DDTi vs HR16DE

Side-by-side reliability comparison

Higher reliability score
HR16DE BUY 80/100
+15 points over YD25DDTi
0 / 100
CAUTION YD25DDTi Nissan
0 / 100
BUY HR16DE Nissan

Specifications

YD25DDTi
HR16DE
Brand
Nissan
Nissan
Verdict
CAUTION
BUY
Reliability
65
80
Years
2001--2016
2006--2020
Displacement
2488 cc
1598 cc
Layout
I4
I4
Type
Diesel
Petrol Na
Power
144--190 hp
114--117 hp
Known Issues
2
0
Total Risk Cost
€1,100--€2,800
€0--€0

Character

YD25DDTi

"Navara/Pathfinder/X-Trail. Timing chain (simplex — can stretch). Turbo failure. EGR. Injector issues. Exhaust manifold cracks. Well-used in harsh conditions. Check service history."

HR16DE

"Juke/Qashqai/Note engine. Simple chain-driven. Reliable daily. Adequate performance."

Issues Comparison

YD25DDTi 2

▲ HIGH
Timing chain stretch (simplex) €800--€2,000 100,000 km--180,000 km
● MODERATE
Exhaust manifold cracking €300--€800 80,000 km--150,000 km

HR16DE 0

No documented issues.

Models

YD25DDTi 6

Navara D40 2005--2015 Murano Z51 2008--2014 Pathfinder R51 2005--2012 Navara D40 2010--2015 Navara D40 2005--2015 Pathfinder R51 2005--2012

HR16DE 37

Micra K11 1992--2003 Micra K11 1992--2000 Micra K11 2000--2003 Micra K12 2003--2010 Micra K12 2003--2010 Micra K12 2003--2010 Note E11 2006--2013 Almera N15 1995--2000 Almera N15 1995--2000 Juke F16 2020--present Note E12 2013--2020 Micra K13 2011--2017 Note E12 2013--2020 Micra K13 2010--2017 Note E13 2021--present Qashqai J12 2021--present Qashqai J12 2021--present Qashqai J12 2021--present Qashqai J12 2021--present Qashqai J11 2014--2017 Juke F15 2010--2019 NV200 M20 2010--2022 Note E11 2006--2013 Micra K12 2005--2010 Micra K12 2005--2010 Qashqai J10 2007--2013 Juke F15 2010--2014 Juke F16 2022--present Juke F16 2022--present Almera N16 2000--2006 Primera P11 1996--2001 Primera P12 2002--2008 Almera N16 2000--2006 Almera Tino V10 2000--2006 Primera P11 1999--2001 Almera N16 2000--2006 Primera P12 2002--2008
Full YD25DDTi Report Full HR16DE Report