OM639 1.5d vs 4A91/4A92
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
OM639 1.5d
"Mercedes-developed 1.5 three-cylinder common-rail diesel (OM639, 68 or 95 hp) shared by the Mitsubishi Colt Z30 1.5 DI-D (2004-2008) and the Smart Forfour 454 1.5 CDI (2004-2006). Timing chain, hydraulic lifters, IHI turbo. German used-car guides expect few problems apart from the usual diesel wear at high mileage - turbo, EGR valve and sooted injectors. One engine guide is harsher, reporting cylinder-head cracks and oil burning from a clogged oil separator. Avoid cars used only for short trips. Rare, so few mechanics know it."
4A91/4A92
"Colt Z30, Lancer CY, ASX. 1.5 (4A91) and 1.6 (4A92) MIVEC with port injection, a timing chain and no turbo - simple and durable. The known weak spot is oil consumption from piston rings or valve-stem seals past about 100,000 km (ASX 1.6 2010-2012 named), plus minor oil leaks. Valve clearances on the 1.6 need manual checks. Keep oil changes short."