M119 vs M104
Side-by-side reliability comparison
Specifications
Character
M119
"Mercedes' four-cam, 32-valve V8 of 1989-1998: 500 SL (R129), 400 E/500 E and E 420/E 500 (W124), S 420/S 500 (W140) and CL (C140), also the E 420 W210 and G 500. A strong engine that handles high mileage - around 400,000 km with proper care - but the plastic timing-chain guide rails age and can break, so chain, tensioner and rails should be renewed as prevention (about EUR 1,500). Cars from about 1992-1996 have engine wiring looms whose insulation crumbles, causing misfires and no-starts. Early cars also need distributor caps and rotors, and the plastic cam oiler tubes can cause tapping. Ask for proof of the chain-rail and harness work."
M104
"Twin-cam 24-valve straight-six of the W124, W140, R129, early W202 and W210. The block and bottom end are long-lived - 400,000 km and more are documented. Two things to check: the engine wiring harness on cars built about 1993-1995, whose insulation crumbles (a new, later-type harness is the permanent fix), and the head gasket, which can weep or blow with age, usually after overheating, so the cooling system and fan clutch must be healthy."