Instinct says the V8 is the premium choice. Eight cylinders, 4.4 litres, twin turbos, 408 hp at launch and up to 530 hp in its last form — the N63 is BMW's flagship engine in the 5, 6, 7 and 8 Series and the X5. The six-cylinder B58 looks like the sensible step down. On reliability, the data flips that completely: the "lesser" six is one of the best engines BMW has ever built, and the flagship V8 is one of its worst.
Quick answer: Buy the B58 (89/100, BEST). Avoid the original N63 (2008–2014, 43/100, AVOID) — its "hot-V" layout parks the turbos inside the engine valley, cooking injectors and valve stem seals — the oil-consumption repair alone is €2,800–4,500 — and early engines also stretch their timing chains. The revised N63TU (2012 on) is better at 62/100 (CAUTION) but still burns oil. More power on paper, far more pain in practice.
The flagship trap: N63 — 43/100 (AVOID)
The N63 (2008–2014, 408 hp) was BMW's first turbocharged V8, and its defining feature is also its downfall. The turbos sit in the V between the cylinder banks — compact and responsive, but it traps enormous heat around everything mounted nearby:
| Problem | Severity | Repair cost |
|---|---|---|
| Timing chain stretch and guide-rail breakage | Critical | — |
| Excessive oil consumption — valve stem seals | High | €2,800–4,500 |
| Piezo injector failure | High | — |
The injectors live in that heat; BMW replaced them as needed under a Customer Care Package for early engines that also covered a timing-chain check, and settled US class actions over oil consumption. It's a glorious engine to drive and a famously expensive one to own out of warranty.
The revised N63TU (2012→, 449–530 hp, in the later 550i/M550i, 650i, 750i, X5 50i and M850i) scores 62/100 (CAUTION): oil consumption remains its main fault and led to a second settlement, chain and tensioner wear is still reported, and injectors fail less often.
Found in: BMW 5 Series, 6 Series, 7 Series, X5 (N63TU also 8 Series).
The "lesser" engine that isn't: B58 — 89/100 (BEST)
The B58 (2015→, up to 387 hp) is a 3.0-litre straight-six — conventional layout, turbo on the outside where it can breathe. Toyota trusted it for the GR Supra. Its fault list is mild next to the V8's:
| Problem | Severity | Repair cost |
|---|---|---|
| Oil pump plastic ring cracks — oil pressure loss (2018–2022 engines) | High | €1,100–5,500 |
| PCV diaphragm in the valve cover / valve cover gasket — oil smoke, leaks | Moderate | €920–2,350 |
| Coolant loss — expansion tank or cap, electric water pump | Moderate | — |
| Plastic charge pipe crack | Minor | €80–200 |
Found in: BMW 340i, 440i, 540i, M240i, M340i, X3 M40i, Z4 M40i — and the Toyota GR Supra 3.0.
The 46-point gap
| N63 | N63TU | B58 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Layout | 4.4L twin-turbo V8 (hot-V) | 4.4L twin-turbo V8 (hot-V) | 3.0L turbo straight-six |
| Power | 408 hp | 449–530 hp | up to 387 hp |
| Score | 43/100 | 62/100 | 89/100 |
| Verdict | AVOID | CAUTION | BEST |
| Worst fault | Timing chain / guide rails | Oil consumption | Oil pump ring (€1,100–5,500) |
Same brand, same era, same cars in several cases — and a 46-point reliability gap to the original V8, 27 points even to the revised one. That's the cost of putting turbochargers in an oven.
The verdict
If you're shopping a used 5 Series, 7 Series or X5 and the V8 badge is tempting you, step back to the B58. You give up headline horsepower and keep the money that the N63's injectors and oil habit would have taken. The straight-six is faster than you need and tougher than you'd hope.
Only consider an N63 — preferably an N63TU — with documented oil-consumption, chain and injector work and a budget for the next round — and even then, know what you're buying.
For the N63 against its Mercedes rival, see N63 vs M278; for the B58 against BMW's other troubled turbo six, N54 vs B58.
Scores are calculated from documented issues, repair costs, and failure patterns. Reviewed by the EngineScope editorial team. Methodology →